Is a week in a foster home helpful or hurtful to a shelter dog? A new study provides more evidence that foster care is the best placement for animals’ well-being. While previous research has focused on dogs’ well-being during sleepovers and field trips outside the shelter, the new research provides insight into the effects of week-long fostering and co-housing dogs upon their return to the shelter.
This research, which was part of the Arizona State University/Virginia Tech/ Maddie’s Nationwide Fostering Study, examined the experiences of 84 dogs from 2 different U.S. shelters. Each dog spent five days in the shelter, seven days in a foster home and an additional five days at the shelter afterward. During the last five days of the study, dogs were either housed alone or with a familiar or unfamiliar kennel mate. Cortisol, the body’s primary stress hormone, was measured through daily urine testing, while accelerometers mounted on the dogs’ collars measured their activity.
Here are three important takeaways from this research:
A week in foster care clearly lowered stress. “This is one of the most exciting findings of the study!” says Lisa Gunter, PhD, CAAB, CBCC-KA, lead author of the study and Assistant Professor, Animal Behavior & Welfare at Virginia Tech. “As we found in our previous work on short-term fostering (of a night or two), dogs’ cortisol and activity are improved when living in a foster home. When we compared the impact of weeklong fostering to that of short-term fostering on dogs’ cortisol levels, we found double the effect!”
Dogs rested more in homes than in shelters. Ensuring adequate rest is especially important because poor sleep quality has been linked to impulsivity and lowered inhibition in many types of mammals. “Dogs being able to rest in the shelter is a good indicator of their welfare,” says Gunter. “The shelter is a noisy, unpredictable environment, so dogs engaging in rest, not just in the evening, but throughout the day, is important for their physical and mental health.”
Upon return from foster, having a familiar kennel mate was helpful, but a new one wasn’t. Gunter tells us, “We think this finding is particularly useful because it has implications for foster-return and intake procedures. Entering a shelter is recognized as a stressful event, and living with a familiar dog may provide a form of social buffering that lessens its impact. Shelters may want to reconsider whether housing with a familiar dog could improve dogs’ welfare during the initial days in the shelter following foster care or dogs that are surrendered by their owners or found together.”
Notably, one finding from this study aligns with previous research: going back to the shelter was not harmful to the dogs. Upon return to the shelter, the dogs’ cortisol levels rose again to about the same place they were when the dogs left the shelter but went no higher, signaling that dogs were not more stressed in the shelter after foster care as they were before they went.
“Currently, it is unknown what the beneficial limits of fostering are for dogs living in shelters, but we’d like to explore even longer durations in future research studies,” says Gunter.

